Your threshold heart rate — LTHR, for lactate threshold heart rate — is the heart rate you hold at your threshold: the highest intensity you can sustain for a long time, about an hour for a trained cyclist. For a rider with a heart-rate strap, it is what FTP is for a rider with a power meter: the anchor everything else follows from.
Your heart-rate zones are percentages of it (Power and heart-rate zones). Your training load, when it comes from heart rate, is scaled to it: an hour at your threshold heart rate is worth 100 (Measuring training load with heart rate). Get it wrong, and your zones shift, and your loads with them.
Why threshold rather than maximum
Plenty of zone systems still use a percentage of maximum heart rate. Joe Friel, who popularized heart-rate zones for cyclists, prefers threshold heart rate, for two reasons.
- Threshold is what matters for training. It is the line between an effort you can sustain and one that will soon end. It doesn’t sit at the same percentage of maximum from one rider to the next: two riders with the same maximum can have their threshold at quite different heart rates, and a grid based on maximum would give them the same zones.
- Threshold heart rate can be measured without going all the way. Maximum heart rate takes an all-out effort; threshold heart rate a sustained one, hard but controlled.
Maximum heart rate still has a job: together with your resting heart rate, it gives your heart-rate reserve, which heart-rate load is calculated on. You still need to know it.
Why 220 − age misleads
The best-known formula, maximum heart rate = 220 − age, never came from a study. It comes from a chart published in 1971: a line drawn by eye through about ten sets of measurements, never presented as a formula. Robergs and Landwehr, who traced its history in 2002, point out that age-based formulas are off, as a standard error, by 7 to 11 beats from one person to another of the same age.
In 2001, Tanaka and colleagues redid the sums over 351 studies and nearly 19,000 people: 208 − 0.7 × age. It is the best of the age-based formulas; mainly, it corrects 220 − age’s underestimate after 40. But it doesn’t narrow the spread between people: that is what an average is.
At 45, the formula says 177. Your real maximum could be 167 or 187, and nothing in the formula tells you which. Any zones built on it all shift by as much: on a grid in steps of 10% of maximum, that is half a zone.
A maximum heart rate worked out from age is a starting point, not a measurement. It beats having none, and should be replaced as soon as you’ve seen a higher one.
The 30-minute test
The reference field test for threshold heart rate is Joe Friel’s:
- Warm up for 15 minutes.
- Ride 30 minutes at the hardest pace you can hold for the whole time, alone, on a route with no stops: no lights, junctions, or descents that break the effort. Keep it steady, with no sprint for the line.
- Note your average heart rate over the last 20 minutes, leaving out the first 10.
- Recover for 10 to 15 minutes.
That average is your threshold heart rate. The first ten minutes are left out because the heart takes several minutes to catch up with the effort: counting them would pull the average down.
How good the test is has been measured in runners and triathletes: heart rate over a 30-minute time trial did not differ, on average, from heart rate at the threshold measured with blood lactate, with a standard error of 8 beats between athletes. A solid marker, then, though not a lab measurement.
Alone, and not in a race. Friel insists on it: not in a race, not with training partners. With others, you go harder than alone, and the average would no longer be your threshold’s.
Other tests
- The 20-minute test. If you do the 20-minute FTP test wearing a heart-rate strap, your average heart rate over those 20 minutes is a good pointer to your threshold heart rate. The effort is a little more intense than over 30 minutes, so it may come out slightly higher. One test, two markers.
- The Conconi test. On an effort that steps up in stages, it looks for the point where heart rate stops rising in a straight line with speed. You still come across it, but it has been challenged: in fourteen trained runners, the bend appeared in only nine, and above the threshold measured with lactate.
- The lab. An exercise test with blood samples measures lactate at every step and pins the threshold down precisely. It’s the reference, but it costs money, and you won’t redo it every six weeks.
And maximum heart rate?
It is read off a truly all-out effort, at the very end:
- at the end of a ramp test, when you can no longer hold the step: the highest value before you stop;
- on a short hill, all out: two to three very hard minutes, and a full sprint over the last 20 to 30 seconds. The highest value near the top is your maximum.
Keep the highest value you have really seen, in a race or in training, rather than a formula. Just beware of a single isolated spike: a strap that rubs can show a number your heart never reached.
These tests take a maximal, or near-maximal, effort. If you have any doubt about your health, ask a doctor before doing them.
When to retest
Threshold heart rate usually moves less than FTP, Friel notes: a rider who improves holds more watts at threshold, at much the same heart rate. Retest at the start of a season, after a long break, or when your zones no longer match how things feel: an endurance activity that drifts into zone 3 without you noticing, for example. Always repeat the same test, in the same conditions.
In Komeak
Your threshold heart rate is set in Profile, Cycling. You say you train with heart rate, then enter your three markers: threshold, maximum and usual resting heart rate. Your seven heart-rate zones, Friel’s, are computed from them straight away.
- Without a measured maximum, Komeak offers to estimate it from your age, with Tanaka’s formula, and marks it “estimated, provisional”. A value you’ve measured replaces it.
- Tests are explained step by step, under Evaluation tests: Friel’s test (30 min) for threshold heart rate, the ramp test and the all-out hill effort for maximum heart rate. Coggan’s test (20 min) also asks for your average heart rate, if you tracked it: it gives an approximate threshold heart rate alongside your FTP.
- You can plan a test for a given day, from the Cycling page or from a threshold heart rate Komeak estimated: the Thresholds card on the home screen reminds you, and keeps it, flagged overdue, until you have done it, rescheduled it or canceled it. Once it’s done, I’ve done it asks for the day of the test and the value you read — the average over the last 20 minutes, or the highest heart rate —, records it as determined by a test, and computes your activities since that day again.
- Your markers are checked against each other: a resting heart rate that reaches your threshold, or a threshold that reaches your maximum, is refused.
- Your thresholds are dated. Edit corrects a typing mistake; New version opens a new period, and your past activities keep the threshold heart rate their load was computed with.
- Your history has its thresholds too. Drop the archive of the platform you used: Komeak proposes a profile for each year before yours, with the threshold and maximum heart rates set on your bike computer, or those your efforts show when they beat them by 3%. You validate or correct each, the latest first, and its activities are computed again with it.
- Threshold heart rate is the reference on every activity: your average heart rate as a share of it, a line on the heart-rate chart and on the sustained heart-rate curve, from one minute to an hour. Your best 20-minute heart rate reads against it there.
- Komeak proposes a higher threshold heart rate when your rides show it. It takes your highest average heart rate over 20 minutes on the bike since your threshold heart rate last changed, as it is, and proposes it as soon as it is 3% above yours — on the home screen, and on the activity it comes from. You can dismiss it: it only comes back at 5%. From 7%, it stays until you accept it. Accepting opens a new version, with Friel’s zones for it, without touching the past.
Sources
- Friel J., The Cyclist’s Training Bible, 5th ed., VeloPress, 2018.
- Robergs R. A., Landwehr R., “The surprising history of the ‘HRmax = 220 − age’ equation”, Journal of Exercise Physiology Online, 5(2), 2002, pp. 1–10.
- Tanaka H., Monahan K. D., Seals D. R., “Age-predicted maximal heart rate revisited”, Journal of the American College of Cardiology, 37(1), 2001, pp. 153–156.
- McGehee J. C., Tanner C. J., Houmard J. A., “A comparison of methods for estimating the lactate threshold”, Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 19(3), 2005, pp. 553–558.
- Jones A. M., Doust J. H., “The Conconi test is not valid for estimation of the lactate turnpoint in runners”, Journal of Sports Sciences, 15(4), 1997, pp. 385–394. doi:10.1080/026404197367173
- Allen H., Coggan A., McGregor S., Training and Racing with a Power Meter, 3rd ed., VeloPress, 2019.