No power meter, no heart-rate strap, a ride recorded by a phone or a basic computer: can the activity’s load still be measured? Yes, and by the one instrument everyone has. After the ride, answer one question: how hard was that?
It is simpler than power or heart rate, and better supported by research than its simplicity suggests. It stands beside power and heart rate in the article on training load, and it can take over from heart rate when there is none.
A scale made to be shared
Gunnar Borg, a Swedish psychologist, spent his career building scales to put numbers on perceived effort. The one used for a whole session is a version of his CR-10 scale, from 1 to 10, adapted by Carl Foster. Each landmark has a label, and the labels are what make a rating comparable from one day to the next:
| Rating | Label |
|---|---|
| 1 | Very, very easy |
| 2 | Easy |
| 3 | Moderate |
| 4 | Somewhat hard |
| 5 | Hard |
| 7 | Very hard |
| 10 | Maximal |
6, 8 and 9 sit between the labels. What counts is not the number itself but that a 7 means the same thing to you next month as today.
Foster’s method: rating × duration
In 2001, Carl Foster proposed the session RPE (RPE for rating of perceived exertion): one rating for the whole activity, multiplied by its duration in minutes. It gives a load in arbitrary units: 90 minutes rated 3 make 270; 45 minutes rated 8 make 360.
Foster asked for the rating about thirty minutes after the end of the activity, so that the last effort does not color the whole of it, and for the activity as a whole, not its hardest moment.
He compared these loads with ones computed from heart rate: from one session to the next, the two moved together. A 2017 review of the research, by Haddad and colleagues, found the method valid in a wide range of sports and of athletes, and listed what influences it, among them when and how the rating is asked.
Why it works
Your effort is felt through everything at once: breathing, legs, heart, heat, the day you’ve had. A sensor sees one of those. The rating adds them up, which is why it catches what sensors don’t: the same ride feels harder on a bad night’s sleep, and the rating says so.
That makes it worth giving even with a sensor. Power says what you produced; the rating says what it cost you. An ordinary activity that felt very hard says a lot about how you are that day.
Its limits
- It’s subjective, and personal. One rider’s 7 is not another’s. It compares you with yourself, over weeks. And the first weeks are for learning the scale: ratings settle with practice.
- It remembers badly. The last effort, the group, the way the day ended color the memory. Rate soon after, and the whole activity.
- It’s coarse. Rating × minutes weighs effort and time on equal terms: it follows a trend well, and compares two very different activities less well than a sensor does.
- It isn’t on the same scale as the others. Foster’s units are arbitrary: they cannot be added to loads computed from power or heart rate, where one hour at threshold scores 100. To mix them, the rating has to be brought onto that scale, which is a choice to make, not a measure.
In Komeak
The rating takes two seconds: from 1 to 10, with the labels above. Komeak asks for it as soon as an activity arrives, on the home page, one activity at a time, the most recent first, for those of the past seven days that have none. After a week, a rating is a memory and the home page stops asking, but the activity’s menu gives or changes your rating at any time: change it, and the load and the form that follow are computed again.
- It sets the load when no sensor can: neither usable power nor heart rate on that activity. The page then says “Calculated from your rating”, with a precision of “fair”. Until you rate it, the load is an estimate from the duration and the sport, with a “low” precision, and the activity says a rating is still to give.
- With a sensor, it completes the load: the load stays the measured one, and your rating is kept beside it on the activity’s page.
- It is put on the load scale by a line of our own: the rating gives an intensity, from 0.52 for a 1 to 1.15 for a 10, then scored like power’s, intensity² × hours × 100. An hour rated 8, between “very hard” and “maximal”, is worth about an hour at threshold. This is a convention, anchored on those two landmarks; no published study validates its exact line.
| One hour rated | 3, moderate | 5, hard | 7, very hard | 8 | 10, maximal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Load | 44 | 64 | 88 | 102 | 132 |
- It asks the whole activity: “How did you find the effort?”, with your effort over the whole activity in mind, not its end. Foster waited thirty minutes; Komeak asks right away, because a rating given warm is better than one never given.
- With a sensor, it is compared with your habit: Komeak learns, from your measured and rated activities of the six months around, the rating you usually give for a given intensity and duration — two activities of the same load are not rated alike, a short interval session and a long ride. From five rated activities on, the Rating line of the Komeak analysis says whether you rated this one harder than usual, easier, or as usual. It does not say why: a single rating cannot. Fatigue, heat, short sleep, an illness coming on show in repetition, not in one activity. You are only ever compared with yourself.
Sources
- Foster C. et al., “A new approach to monitoring exercise training”, Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 15(1), 2001, pp. 109–115.
- Borg G., Borg’s Perceived Exertion and Pain Scales, Human Kinetics, 1998.
- Haddad M., Stylianides G., Djaoui L., Dellal A., Chamari K., “Session-RPE method for training load monitoring: validity, ecological usefulness, and influencing factors”, Frontiers in Neuroscience, 11, 2017, article 612.