Komeak
EN
Request access

All articlesAnalysis

Zone 2 and the endurance base: why ride slowly

Why top endurance athletes train mostly at low intensity, what polarized training is, what studies on cyclists measured, and how easy easy really is.

To get faster, ride slowly. It sounds like a paradox, and yet it is what the best endurance athletes do: most of their hours are easy, at a pace where they could hold a conversation. The endurance base is built at low intensity, and the hard sessions are added on top of it, not in its place.

What the best athletes do

Stephen Seiler gathered studies describing the training of endurance athletes competing at national and international level, training 10 to 13 times a week. They converge on the same distribution: about 80% of sessions at low intensity, about 20% dominated by high-intensity work, such as intervals close to maximum oxygen uptake.

To describe it, Seiler uses three intensities, bounded by the two thresholds a laboratory measures from your breathing or blood lactate — not to be confused with the seven zones of power and heart-rate grids:

Intensity Where it sits Typical training
Low Below the first threshold Long, easy activities
Moderate Between the two thresholds Tempo, threshold work
High Above the second threshold Intervals close to maximum oxygen uptake

In a study with Kjerland of eleven junior cross-country skiers, measured over 32 days, endurance sessions were split, by heart rate, 75% low, 8% moderate and 17% high. Plenty of easy, some hard, very little in between: Seiler calls this distribution polarized.

Why so easy

According to Seiler, the two complement each other: long, low-intensity training, together with a few very intense sessions, gives the body what it needs to adapt at a level of stress it can sustain. Easy hours build the base and can be repeated day after day; hard sessions bring what easy hours don’t, but they cost recovery.

The review finds no convincing evidence the other way: in athletes who are already well trained, studies that added more high-intensity intervals did not show lasting gains in performance.

What studies on cyclists have measured

Neal and colleagues had twelve trained cyclists follow two six-week periods, in random order, separated by four weeks without training. Same riders, two distributions of their time:

LowModerateHighPolarized6.4 h a weekThreshold7.5 h a week
The two periods of Neal's study, in share of training time by intensity, with the hours a week each one took.

With fewer hours, the polarized period gave greater gains: peak power up 8% against 3%, power at the lactate threshold up 9% against 2%, and much longer endurance at high intensity.

Thomas Stöggl and Billy Sperlich compared four approaches over nine weeks in 48 well-trained endurance athletes, cyclists among them: high volume, threshold, high-intensity intervals, and polarized. The polarized group improved the most on most measures — its maximum oxygen uptake rose by 11.7% — while the high-volume and threshold groups saw no further gains.

How easy is easy

Below the first threshold, without a lab, is easy to recognize: you can still talk in full sentences. Persinger, Foster and their colleagues showed it: the point where speaking first becomes difficult falls almost exactly at the ventilatory threshold, on the bike as on the treadmill.

On power and heart-rate grids, that is roughly the territory of zones 1 and 2 — “Endurance” in Coggan’s grid, “Aerobic endurance” in Friel’s (Power and heart-rate zones). Zone 3, tempo, already sits in between: pleasant to ride, but it asks for more recovery.

The trap is in the details: an endurance activity on hilly roads drifts into zone 3 on every climb. To keep it easy, you have to ease off on the climbs, change down a gear, and let others go.

Long, too

The endurance base is not just about intensity, it is also about duration: holding your pace for hours without your body giving way. That is what cardiac drift measures, ride after ride. When it holds over a duration, you can lengthen your endurance activities; when it gives way, stay at that duration a little longer.

What it doesn’t mean

  • Not only easy. A polarized distribution keeps hard sessions: about a fifth of the sessions, or of the time. Easy hours alone don’t make one.
  • 80% of sessions is not 80% of the time. Seiler counts sessions, Neal counts time: an interval session includes its warm-up and its recoveries, so hard minutes take up less of the time than hard sessions do of the week (Polarized or sweet spot?).
  • The studies followed trained athletes. Seiler’s athletes trained 10 to 13 times a week; Neal’s cyclists rode about six and a half hours a week in the polarized period.

In Komeak

Each activity’s time in zones is on its page, for power and for heart rate: one bar per zone, in its color, with its duration above it. Detail opens the table: the zone, its range, the duration and the share of the time. An endurance activity should live in zones 1 and 2; when a good share went into zone 3, you can see it at a glance.

  • Lines take the color of their zone: on the activity’s charts, you see where each climb took you, from the blue of the easy stretches to the red of the hard ones.
  • The preview after an upload already shows, in one thin bar, how the activity splits across your zones.
  • The Training type line of the Komeak analysis names the activity by what it worked, on its effort blocks against your thresholds: “An endurance activity”, or “A recovery activity” when it stayed short and easy enough — and, when the blocks went higher, tempo or threshold work, which says the activity wasn’t the endurance you had planned. Read as endurance, it also says where the time went instead of zone 2: “which often drifted to tempo”, or “too often left in zone 1”, each with its advice.
  • The Regularity line says whether the effort was steady from start to finish or choppy with surges; in endurance, surges tire you without building the base, and it then advises an even pace, on climbs and accelerations alike.
  • The Endurance line tells you whether your endurance held over the activity’s duration, and advises you to lengthen your endurance activities or to stay with activities of this duration in zone 2.
Sources
  • Seiler S., “What is best practice for training intensity and duration distribution in endurance athletes?”, International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 5(3), 2010, pp. 276–291.
  • Seiler K. S., Kjerland G. Ø., “Quantifying training intensity distribution in elite endurance athletes: is there evidence for an ‘optimal’ distribution?”, Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 16(1), 2006, pp. 49–56.
  • Neal C. M. et al., “Six weeks of a polarized training-intensity distribution leads to greater physiological and performance adaptations than a threshold model in trained cyclists”, Journal of Applied Physiology, 114(4), 2013, pp. 461–471.
  • Stöggl T., Sperlich B., “Polarized training has greater impact on key endurance variables than threshold, high intensity, or high volume training”, Frontiers in Physiology, 5, 2014, article 33.
  • Persinger R., Foster C., Gibson M., Fater D. C., Porcari J. P., “Consistency of the talk test for exercise prescription”, Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 36(9), 2004, pp. 1632–1636.
On the home pageNever a number alone

Your next peak starts here.

Komeak is in private beta. Tell us how you ride, and we'll let you know when your place is ready.

Request access