The bottle is the simplest thing in cycling, and one of the least understood. Two pieces of advice face each other: “drink before you are thirsty, or your performance collapses”, and “drink to thirst, the body knows”. Research has measured both, and the answer depends on the duration, the heat, and on you.
What you sweat
Sweating varies enormously from one person to the next, and with conditions. The American College of Sports Medicine’s position stand on fluid replacement, written by Sawka and colleagues, recommends for that reason a customized hydration plan rather than a common rule, and gives the method for building one: weigh yourself before and after an activity. The weight lost, plus what you drank, is what you sweated.
Take the measurement several times: in cool weather and in heat, on an easy activity and on a hard one. You will know what your body asks for in each case, and that is the only figure that concerns you.
The 2% threshold, and what the field says
The ACSM sets as the goal, during exercise, to avoid losing more than 2% of body weight, beyond which performance drops. Eric Goulet pooled the studies that measure the effect of dehydration on a cycling time trial in real conditions: five studies, 39 subjects, 26 °C and 86 minutes on average. Up to 4% of body weight lost, dehydration did not change performance; the intensity and duration of the effort mattered far more. And drinking to thirst gave better time trials than drinking less — about 5% more power — or than drinking more.
The two only contradict each other on the surface. The 2% threshold comes mostly from studies where the effort is imposed and time to exhaustion is measured; in the field, the rider sets their own pace, and thirst does its job well over an hour and a half in mild weather. Beyond that — a six-hour day, a heatwave — studies are lacking, and thirst has known limits: it comes late, and it goes quiet when you are concentrating.
Overdrinking: the other danger
Drinking beyond thirst is not a safety margin. At the 2002 Boston Marathon, Almond and colleagues measured the blood sodium of 488 runners at the finish: 13% had hyponatremia, blood too diluted, and 0.6% at a critical level. The main risk factor was having gained weight during the race — drunk more than sweated — along with a finishing time over four hours. Hyponatremia can kill; a cyclist’s dehydration over one day almost never does.
On a long day, the rule that follows fits in one sentence: you should not weigh more at the finish than at the start.
What to drink
Water is enough on a short activity. On a long one, the ACSM notes that drinks with carbohydrate and electrolytes bring a benefit over water alone in certain circumstances: carbohydrate, because it is the energy the next climb needs (Pacing a long climb); sodium, because it leaves with sweat. Drink, gel or solid food: the form matters less than the amount.
Before, after, and in the heat
Start hydrated: drink in the hours before, early enough for the excess to be passed before you set off. Afterwards, replace what is missing, the sooner the closer the next activity is: the scales say how much (Riding day after day).
In hot weather everything rises: sweat, heart rate at the same effort, cardiac drift, which dehydration accentuates according to Coyle. That is the case where thirst is least sufficient, and where the scales are most useful.
In Komeak
The Endurance line of the Komeak analysis says whether your endurance held through the whole activity, reading the drift of your heart rate against power or, without it, against speed on the flat. A hot day or a forgotten bottle make it give way without your base being at fault: before reading a missing base into it, ask yourself what you drank.
- The activity’s temperature is in its summary, from your device’s sensor, in the sun or the wind as it was worn: an activity where endurance gave way is re-read with it.
- The heart-rate curve of the activity page compares your sustained heart rates with those of the last 90 days in the same sport, without talking of records: a higher heart rate on a hot activity is no progress, and Komeak does not celebrate it.
Sources
- Sawka M. N., Burke L. M., Eichner E. R., Maughan R. J., Montain S. J., Stachenfeld N. S., “American College of Sports Medicine position stand. Exercise and fluid replacement”, Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 39(2), 2007, pp. 377–390.
- Goulet E. D. B., “Effect of exercise-induced dehydration on time-trial exercise performance: a meta-analysis”, British Journal of Sports Medicine, 45(14), 2011, pp. 1149–1156.
- Almond C. S. D. et al., “Hyponatremia among runners in the Boston Marathon”, The New England Journal of Medicine, 352(15), 2005, pp. 1550–1556.
- Coyle E. F., “Cardiovascular drift during prolonged exercise and the effects of dehydration”, International Journal of Sports Medicine, 19(suppl. 2), 1998, pp. S121–S124.