A heart-rate strap, or a watch that reads it, is often the first sensor a cyclist owns, long before a power meter. It is enough to measure training load, the number that says what an activity cost you (Training load: what an activity really cost you). It is also a different kind of measure from power, and that is worth understanding before trusting it.
What your heart says that watts don’t
Power is what you produced. Heart rate is how your body responded. Two riders holding 200 W do not pay the same price for it, and neither does one rider on two different days: after a bad night, in the heat, on the fifth day of a hard week, the same watts come with more beats.
For a load meant to say what the activity cost you, this is an asset. It is also what makes heart rate harder to read than power.
Banister’s method: weigh each minute
Heart rate alone does not make a load: a minute at 170 beats costs far more than a minute at 140, and by how much has to come from somewhere. In 1991, Eric Banister set out how to weigh every minute of an activity by how hard it was for the heart, in two steps. It is the TRIMP, his “training impulse”, of the article on training load.
1. The share of your heart-rate reserve. Your reserve is the room between your resting heart rate and your maximum. At 50 beats a minute at rest and 190 at maximum, 120 beats is 50% of your reserve, 170 is 86%.
2. An exponential weight. The share of reserve is multiplied by a factor that grows exponentially with it: Banister fitted it on blood lactate, which also rises faster than the effort does. So the weight does not rise in step with your heart rate, but faster. He fitted it separately for men (an exponent of 1.92) and for women (1.67).
The load of an activity is the sum of its minutes’ weights. To speak the same language as power, the sum is brought to the same scale: one hour at your threshold heart rate scores 100.
Two things follow from the shape of that curve:
- An hour 20 beats under your threshold is worth about two thirds of an hour at it (64 in the figure), and an hour 40 beats under it about 40. The easy hours count, but much less.
- The weight applies minute by minute, not to the average. An activity of surges and recoveries scores more than a steady one at the same average heart rate, because each minute at the top weighs more than the minutes it is balanced by.
Three markers to know
The method needs three numbers, personal to you:
- Your resting heart rate: the usual one, lying down, after waking up. It matters less than the other two.
- Your threshold heart rate: the heart rate you hold at your threshold. A common field test, from Joe Friel, is thirty minutes at the hardest steady pace you can hold, taking the average of the last twenty (Threshold heart rate: finding it without a lab).
- Your maximum heart rate: the highest your heart reaches, in a maximal effort. Formulas guess it from age: the best known today is 208 − 0.7 × age (Tanaka, 2001), and such formulas are off by 7 to 11 beats from one person to another of the same age. A starting point, not a measure.
They also give your heart-rate zones, the bands from recovery to maximal effort, in which you can read how long an activity spent (Power and heart-rate zones).
Where heart rate misleads
- It lags. At the start of an effort, the heart takes time to catch up; at its end, it takes time to come down. A fifteen-second sprint is over before it has risen, and a series of short intervals shows up as a gentle wave rather than as the peaks they were. Because the weight grows with intensity, short, hard efforts weigh less than they cost.
- It drifts. At the same power, heart rate rises over a long activity, and with heat, dehydration, altitude or too little sleep. The load then goes up although your legs produced the same; your body did pay for it, but not the training stimulus the effort was meant to give. Measured against power or speed, that drift also tells whether your endurance held (Cardiac drift: measuring your endurance).
- It depends on the sensor. A strap that slips or drops out leaves holes, which a load has to fill in with an assumption.
It remains an excellent measure of long, steady efforts: an endurance ride, a tempo block. For short intervals, power does better; with neither, perceived effort can stand in.
Heart rate or power?
| Power | Heart rate | |
|---|---|---|
| What it says | What you produced | How your body responded |
| Short efforts | Immediate | Late, and blurred |
| Heat, fatigue, sleep | Doesn’t see them | Sees them, and mixes them with the effort |
| What it needs | A power meter, an accurate FTP | A strap, and three markers |
Neither replaces the other: with both on the same activity, the load comes from power, and what the heart does with it says how you are doing.
In Komeak
An activity that holds your heart rate gets its load from it when power can’t give it: no power meter on that ride, an unknown FTP, or a power meter that measured less than half of the moving time. The activity’s page then says “Calculated from your heart rate”, with a precision of “good”: the second level of four, below power.
- You say you measure with heart rate in Profile, Cycling, and enter your three markers there: threshold, maximum and usual resting heart rate. Until they are all known, the page says what is missing and offers to enter it.
- With the morning measurement on the strap, your resting heart rate is no longer a value typed once: each activity takes your current resting heart rate, the median of your measures over the last 60 days, sick days left out. A median does not follow a bad week: a resting heart rate rising with fatigue never lowers your load. The page says which one served — “Current on 3 November” — and a measure never rewrites an activity already computed.
- Without a measured maximum, Komeak starts from an estimate computed from your birth date (Tanaka’s formula) and marks it “estimated, provisional”. You can replace it, or find it with a test: Profile proposes the thirty-minute test, a ramp test and a short maximal climb, each with its protocol, and recalls that a maximal effort calls for medical advice when in doubt.
- Your sex sets the exponent: Komeak uses Banister’s values for men or for women according to what you told it, and the value between the two if you chose not to say.
- A strap that dropped out is accounted for: a stretch with no heart rate is assumed to have carried the average load of what was measured, and below 90% of the moving time, the precision drops by one level. Below half, the heart rate is set aside and the next method takes over.
- Each activity is computed with the thresholds of its date. When one changes, a marker on the form chart says from which day the load is computed differently.
- Your zones and your curve. The activity’s page gives the time spent in each of your heart-rate zones, and the highest heart rate you held from one minute to one hour, set against your best of the last 90 days in the same sport.
- Drift is read on endurance activities only. Without power, Komeak compares speed and heart rate across the two halves of the flat part of a ride of at least one hour with 40 minutes of flat, under 85% of your threshold heart rate: on anything harder or hillier, the comparison would only measure the route or the session.
Sources
- Banister E. W., “Modeling elite athletic performance”, in MacDougall J. D., Wenger H. A., Green H. J. (eds), Physiological Testing of the High-Performance Athlete, Human Kinetics, 1991.
- Morton R. H., Fitz-Clarke J. R., Banister E. W., “Modeling human performance in running”, Journal of Applied Physiology, 69(3), 1990, pp. 1171–1177.
- Achten J., Jeukendrup A. E., “Heart rate monitoring: applications and limitations”, Sports Medicine, 33(7), 2003, pp. 517–538.
- Coyle E. F., González-Alonso J., “Cardiovascular drift during prolonged exercise: new perspectives”, Exercise and Sport Sciences Reviews, 29(2), 2001, pp. 88–92.
- Robergs R. A., Landwehr R., “The surprising history of the ‘HRmax = 220 − age’ equation”, Journal of Exercise Physiology Online, 5(2), 2002, pp. 1–10.
- Tanaka H., Monahan K. D., Seals D. R., “Age-predicted maximal heart rate revisited”, Journal of the American College of Cardiology, 37(1), 2001, pp. 153–156.
- Friel J., The Cyclist’s Training Bible, 5th ed., VeloPress, 2018.