Two schools compete for amateur cyclists’ weeks. The first, polarized, wants most sessions easy, a few very hard, and almost nothing in between. The second, sweet spot, puts the bulk of the work just under threshold, where every minute supposedly pays the most. Both have their arguments, and research settles the question less cleanly than their advocates do.
80/20, counted in sessions
Polarized training comes from observing elite endurance athletes: Seiler found among them about 80% of sessions at low intensity, and about 20% dominated by high-intensity work (The endurance base). The unit matters: these are sessions, not minutes. An interval session counts as one hard session, even if its hard minutes fit in a quarter of an hour.
Sylta, Tønnessen and Seiler measured the gap over 570 sessions of elite cross-country skiers: 96% of the time at low intensity when you count minutes, 87% of sessions when you count by session. The same weeks, two readings. When someone tells you “80/20”, ask what they count in: in minutes, an 80/20 week is far harder than in sessions.
The sweet spot
The sweet spot is an intensity, not a distribution: 88 to 93% of FTP according to Coggan and Allen, the top of tempo and the bottom of threshold in their zones (Power and heart-rate zones).
The argument is one of return on time: intense enough to push the threshold up, not so intense that it costs the recovery of real threshold work or a VO2max session. Hence its success with riders who have six or eight hours a week: sessions of two by twenty minutes or three by fifteen, repeated, that can be strung together without being cooked. The risk, as its own advocates say, is sliding below the band: tempo that tires without targeting anything, the in-between intensity Seiler’s athletes do so little of.
What research says
Among trained athletes, polarized has the edge, but a small and conditional one. The meta-analysis by Silva Oliveira, Boppre and Fonseca pooled seventeen studies and 437 subjects: polarized training improves maximal oxygen uptake more, by a small effect, and only in interventions shorter than twelve weeks and in highly trained athletes. On everything else — time trial, time to exhaustion, power at the second threshold — polarized and the other distributions come out level. The two cycling studies in the endurance base article, Neal and Stöggl, are in that pool, on the favorable side.
Among amateurs, less is known. Magalhães and colleagues followed fourteen recreational cyclists in their forties through sixteen weeks of pyramidal training — lots of easy, less moderate, little hard. Their power at the lactate threshold improved markedly, and time spent at moderate intensity — between the two thresholds, at 2 to 4 mmol of lactate, the domain of tempo and sweet spot — is what best explained the improvement. Not a comparison of models, but it is the amateur public, and it leans towards the middle that polarized training avoids.
Order may matter. In well-trained runners, Filipas and colleagues found that a pyramidal block followed by a polarized one gave the best gains over sixteen weeks, rather than either alone.
What can be kept: no model wins for an amateur. Polarized is the best documented, in athletes who train a lot; moderate work makes recreational cyclists progress; and the hard work remains indispensable in both.
What is only practice
Much of what you read on the subject has not been measured. That sweet spot suits riders under eight to ten hours a week and polarized those above ten or twelve; that eight hours should be split 70/10/20; that you should switch method every two or three months, between two FTP tests; that one key session a week is enough when you ride little — these are coaches’ settings, sensible ones, handed down without a study behind them. Useful as a starting point, not as a rule.
Choosing
- With few hours, sweet spot gives a lot per session; still keep one genuinely hard session and at least one genuinely easy activity, and watch your freshness: the band sits just under threshold, and two badly placed sessions in a week take their toll.
- With more hours, easy can be truly easy and hard truly hard: that is where polarized training was studied, and where it gives its best results.
- Either way, count your hard sessions, not your hard minutes, and make them look like your goal: an hour-long climb is prepared with continuous threshold work more than with 30/30s (Eight weeks to get ready for a cycling trip in the mountains).
In Komeak
The Training type line of the Komeak analysis names each activity by what it worked — recovery, endurance, tempo, threshold, VO2max, anaerobic efforts, sprints — and how: in intervals, in a pyramid, in a ladder, continuous, or unstructured when the effort followed the terrain. That is Seiler’s unit: one activity, one session, easy or hard, whatever the time spent in each zone. Reading back over your week in the Activities tab, you count your hard sessions.
- Time in zone on each activity gives the other reading, in minutes, for power and for heart rate.
- A sweet spot session reads as “tempo, in the sweet spot” or “threshold, in the sweet spot” depending on which side of 91% its blocks sat — between 88 and 94% of FTP, the word is added to the family: both readings describe the same session, astride the border.
- The line also says how the work was done, and advises on the activity itself: blocks that faded, recoveries too short or too long, VO2max at the bottom of its zone, a start without a warm-up, a session just at the dose; an endurance activity that drifted to tempo — Seiler’s gray zone.
Sources
- Seiler S., “What is best practice for training intensity and duration distribution in endurance athletes?”, International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 5(3), 2010, pp. 276–291.
- Sylta Ø., Tønnessen E., Seiler S., “From heart-rate data to training quantification: a comparison of 3 methods of training-intensity analysis”, International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 9(1), 2014, pp. 100–107.
- Allen H., Coggan A. R., McGregor S., Training and Racing with a Power Meter, 3rd ed., VeloPress, 2019.
- Silva Oliveira P., Boppre G., Fonseca H., “Comparison of polarized versus other types of endurance training intensity distribution on athletes’ endurance performance: a systematic review with meta-analysis”, Sports Medicine, 54(8), 2024, pp. 2071–2095.
- Magalhães P. M., Cipriano F., Morais J. E., Bragada J. A., “Effects of a 16-week training program with a pyramidal intensity distribution on recreational male cyclists”, Sports, 12(1), 2024, article 17.
- Filipas L., Bonato M., Gallo G., Codella R., “Effects of 16 weeks of pyramidal and polarized training intensity distributions in well-trained endurance runners”, Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 32(3), 2022, pp. 498–511.